Phonics vs Sight Words

Once upon a time there was a great controversy regarding phonics vs sight words. Well, yes, the controversy still rages in some quarters with advocates on both sides of the debate. And in fact, there are advantages to both.

Advantages of Phonics Instruction

• Many words can be taught at one time in a phonic family. (ex: rat, cat, sat OR cream, dream, steam)
• It teaches students a strategy to sound out unfamiliar words.
• It helps with spelling.
• It avoids "guessing" at a word.
• It makes sense.

• Many common words have irregular spellings. (Ex: is, have, was, come)
• Some pure phonics problems have simple words with unfamiliar meanings to five or six year olds. (Ex: Tom the cop did sob on the cot.)
• Sight words allow a student to read "real" books and sentences with common but irregular words sooner.
• Sight words are particularly helpful for students with auditory problems.

While the controversy will likely continue to rage for years to come, today's parents can help their child read with one simple strategy: teach both!

More Info on the Phonic and Sight Word Debate

Some reading experts advocate a phonics approach to reading; while others advocate for sight word instruction using whole language or other methods.

Both sides have neurological and educational psychology theories behind their preferred strategies.

Both sides quote research to back their claims.

There are classroom teachers and one-on-one tutors who testify to the superiority of one method or the other.

Either side can document cases of children who failed to read with the other method but improved with their method of choice.

Some, sadly, accuse the other side of twisted reasoning or misplaced loyalties.

From the halls of academia, to the circles of kindergarten students, and even to the floor of Congress the debate continues.

So, how does the parent sitting at the kitchen table or snuggled on the couch have confidence to teach reading if the experts don't agree?

Simple. Do what has always worked. Let's just break the process down a bit.

Which strategy (phonics or sight) does a competent reader use?

Both.

Try reading this word: "stringle."

How about this: "flodify."

Could you read it? You used phonics if you did.

You didn't recognize those words? Great, because they don't exist.

But if you were to read those words over and over again, your neurological system would recognize them as sight words.

Here's an analogy. Imagine you have a file cabinet with three drawers marked "A-G" on top; "H-R" in the middle; and "S-Z" on the bottom. If you have a "p" file to put away, you might have to stop and figure out which drawer it belongs in. After repeated use, you "know" that file goes in the middle drawer without having to figure it out.

In the same way, the proficient reader has phonic strategies to decode and encode words, but also reading experience to recognize a vast number of words by sight.

It is interesting to note a progression in academic circles. In the "good old days," classroom students were taught to read using phonics, but taught math facts with a rote-memory system. Then it switched. Strategies were developed to teach comprehension of math reasoning to understand why 25 X 4 = 100. It become more like phonics: explaining why and how. But at the same time, reading changed to a "rote" method via sight recognition.

It should be noted that this is a simplification of reality; in that theorists and teachers have been using a spectrum of methods over the last decades. Nonetheless, it is possible to see the proverbial pendulum swing from "comprehension" to "fact recognition" and back again. And it can be noted that while the overall trend swings in one direction for reading, it may be swinging in the opposite direction for math or other academic subjects.

A Delightfully Simple Model of a Complex Process

For those of you interested in getting your PhD in this subject, the explanation here may seem a bit overly simplistic. Nonetheless, it works.

Let's break reading into three steps.

Pre-reading

Decoding

Reading Competency

Simple Strategy

The strategy we suggest seems a common sense one (but then I suppose everyone thinks their strategy rates highest for common sense.)

1. Use phonics to teach word families. Groups of words can be learned together; and the student learns decoding.

2. Teach sight words needed to read common but phonically irregular or difficult words.

This strategy will work for most children. Guaranteed to work for your child?

Unfortunately, no.

Some children do struggle to read due to a variety of possible learning problems. Depending on the problem, some methods will work better than others.

Balanced Literacy
Read the critique about this educational method.

Return from Phonics vs Sight Words to the Early Reading main page.